Fibre Channel in More Trouble

We have all heard about the problems that QLogic is having and fibre channel’s decline. I even posted something on this back in May.

Now the latest is that Emulex is looking for a buyer. This is not good for those of us that have large fibre channel installations.

Let’s say Emulex gets sold to someone, and the likely competitor is Brocade. That means we are down to two vendors in the fibre channel market place. And if QLogic tries to buy Emulex, we will be down to a single HBA vendor.

Having just a few vendors in a market is not good for the long term, especially in the communications market. Whether it was FDDI, HIPPI, name your interconnect, they all failed to gain enough market share over Ethernet to survive. Fibre channel was the performance leader over Ethernet from about the time it came out until about last year (yes, 10 Gbit/sec Ethernet was out while FC was only 8 Gbit/sec but that is just a small difference). Now 40 Gbit/sec Ethernet cards are hitting the market. FC is still at 16 Gbit/sec, and the cost per Gbit/sec is not looking good for fibre channel

Here's a quick look on the internet for some basic pricing for fibre channel HBA vs. and Ethernet NIC:

 

Item

Performance in Gbit/sec

Cost

Cost per Gbit/sec

Dual Port Emulex

32

$2,645

$82.66

Mellanox 40 Gb Ethernet

40

$980

$24.50

Difference

x3.37

 

Because of volume, Ethernet prices are going to come down a fair amount more than will fibre channel prices. Of course, you have the cost of fibre channel switch ports, which are less than Ethernet today but just like what has happened with 10 GbE switch ports over the last eighteen months, the same will happen for 40 GbE.

It is all about volume. And with storage appliances moving to 40 GbE and RDMA stacks for Ethernet available, fibre channel has no significant advantages. It will not be able to compete given the pricing.

My opinion of course.

Labels: QLogic,fibre channel,Brocade,EtherNet,Emulex

posted by: Henry Newman

Henry Newman, InfoStor Blogger
by Henry Newman
InfoStor Blogger

Henry Newman is CEO and CTO of Instrumental Inc. and has worked in HPC and large storage environments for 29 years. The outspoken Mr. Newman initially went to school to become a diplomat, but was firmly told during his first year that he might be better suited for a career that didn't require diplomatic skills. Diplomacy's loss was HPC's gain.

Previous Posts

Archives